Product comparison · 2 network switches

Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays vs NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports)

14specifications compared
13differ
1identical
29known for one product only

Key differences

The Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays has 32 more basic switching RJ-45 Ethernet ports quantity than the NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports) (48 vs 16). The Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays has 15,000 entries more MAC address table than the NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports) (16000 entries vs 1000 entries). The Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays has 0.9 Gbit/s more maximum data transfer rate than the NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports) (1 Gbit/s vs 0.1 Gbit/s). Dimensions (WxDxH): 438 x 304 x 44 mm on the Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays, 287 x 103 x 27 mm on the NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports). Power requirements: 100-240vAC, 50-60Hz on the Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays, 48VDC, 4.5 power output on the NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports).

Basic switching RJ-45 Ethernet ports quantity
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:48
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):16
MAC address table
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:16000 entries
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):1000 entries
Maximum data transfer rate
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:1 Gbit/s
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):0.1 Gbit/s
Mean time between failures (MTBF)
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:250000 h
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):116009 h
Power consumption (typical)
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:120 W
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):88 W
Data transfer rate
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:1000 Mbit/s
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):100 Mbit/s
Dimensions (WxDxH)
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:438 x 304 x 44 mm
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):287 x 103 x 27 mm
Power requirements
- 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays:100-240vAC, 50-60Hz
- ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports):48VDC, 4.5 power output

Side by side

Differences highlightedShow differences only

Comparison of 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays, ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports)
43 specifications	A Allied Telesis 10/100/1000T x 48 ports Managed Ethernet Layer 3 Switch w/ 4 combo SFP bays View product	B NETGEAR ProSafe 16 Port Switch (with 8 Power x Power over Ethernet (PoE) Ports)View product
Management featuresidentical
Switch typeKnown for one	Managed	Unknown — not stated by the source
Switch layerKnown for one	L3	Unknown — not stated by the source
Ports & interfaces1 differ
Basic switching RJ-45 Ethernet ports quantityDiffers	48	16
Combo SFP ports quantityKnown for one	4	Unknown — not stated by the source
SFP/SFP+ slots quantityKnown for one	4	Unknown — not stated by the source
Network1 differ
Networking standardsDiffers	IEEE 802.1D, IEEE 802.1p, IEEE 802.1Q, IEEE 802.1s, IEEE 802.1w, IEEE 802.1x, IEEE 802.3, IEEE 802.3ab, IEEE 802.3ac, IEEE 802.3u, IEEE 802.3x, IEEE 802.3z	IEEE 802.3af, IEEE 802.3i, IEEE 802.3u, IEEE 802.3x
Full duplexKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
IP routingKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Broadcast storm controlKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Flow control supportKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Link aggregationKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Copper ethernet cabling technologyKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	100BASE-TX, 10BASE-T
Data transmission2 differ
MAC address tableDiffers	16000 entries	1000 entries
ThroughputKnown for one	71.424 Mpps	Unknown — not stated by the source
Maximum data transfer rateDiffers	1 Gbit/s	0.1 Gbit/s
Switching capacityKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	3.2 Gbit/s
Packet buffer memoryKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	0.096 MB
Securityidentical
DHCP featuresKnown for one	DHCP client	Unknown — not stated by the source
Protocols1 differ
Management protocolsKnown for one	SNMP, RMON, IGMP, Telnet	Unknown — not stated by the source
Switching protocolsKnown for one	Ethernet	Unknown — not stated by the source
Data link protocolsDiffers	Ethernet, Fast Ethernet, Gigabit Ethernet	Ethernet, Fast Ethernet
Performance1 differ
Built-in processorKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Processor modelKnown for one	PowerPC	Unknown — not stated by the source
Processor frequencyKnown for one	200 MHz	Unknown — not stated by the source
Internal memoryKnown for one	32 MB	Unknown — not stated by the source
Flash memoryKnown for one	16 MB	Unknown — not stated by the source
Mean time between failures (MTBF)Differs	250000 h	116009 h
Power1 differ
Power consumption (typical)Differs	120 W	88 W
Power over Ethernet (PoE)identical
Power over Ethernet (PoE)Known for one	No	Unknown — not stated by the source
Other features3 differ
Data transfer rateDiffers	1000 Mbit/s	100 Mbit/s
Dimensions (WxDxH)Differs	438 x 304 x 44 mm	287 x 103 x 27 mm
Connectivity technologyKnown for one	Wired	Unknown — not stated by the source
Packet transfer speedKnown for one	14880-1488000 pps	Unknown — not stated by the source
Power requirementsDiffers	100-240vAC, 50-60Hz	48VDC, 4.5 power output
LatencyKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	20 µs for 64-byte frames
Electromagnetic emissionsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	CE mark, commercial, FCC Part 15 Class A, VCCI Class A, EN 55022 (CISPR 22) Class A, C-Tick
Operational conditions2 differ
Storage temperature (T-T)Differs	-25 - 70 °C	10 - 70 °C
Operating relative humidity (H-H)Known for one	5 - 90%	Unknown — not stated by the source
Storage relative humidity (H-H)Differs	5 - 95%	95
Weight & dimensions1 differ
WeightDiffers	4.61 kg	840 g
Certificatesidentical
CertificationKnown for one	FCC Class A certified, C-Tick, EN 61000-3-2, VCCI Class A ITE, EN 61000-3-3, EN55024, EN55022 Class A, FCC Part 15, AS/NZS 3548, IEC 825-2, UL 60950-1, EN 60950-1, CSA C22.2 No. 60950-1-03	Unknown — not stated by the source
Designidentical
SafetyKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	CE mark, commercial; CE/LVD EN60950

A dash means the value is not stated by the source. Unknown values are never counted for or against a product, and there is no overall score.

More network switch comparisons

All network switch comparisons