Product comparison · 2 network switches

D-Link DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot vs NETGEAR 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP)

Add a product
  • 21specifications compared
  • 11differ
  • 10identical
  • 37known for one product only

Key differences

The NETGEAR 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP) has 16 more basic switching RJ-45 Ethernet ports quantity than the D-Link DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot (24 vs 8). The D-Link DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot has 128 more VLANs than the NETGEAR 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP) (256 vs 128). The NETGEAR 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP) has 2.872 MB more packet buffer memory than the D-Link DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot (3 MB vs 0.128 MB). Only the NETGEAR 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP) has power over Ethernet (PoE). Dimensions (WxDxH): 155 x 220 x 37 mm on the D-Link DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot, 440 x 257 x 43 mm on the NETGEAR 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP).

  • Basic switching RJ-45 Ethernet ports quantity
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:8
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):24
  • Number of VLANs
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:256
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):128
  • Packet buffer memory
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:0.128 MB
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):3 MB
  • Power consumption (typical)
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:12.2 W
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):225 W
  • Power over Ethernet (PoE)
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:No
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):Yes
  • Dimensions (WxDxH)
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:155 x 220 x 37 mm
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):440 x 257 x 43 mm
  • Operating temperature (T-T)
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:32 - 104 °F
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):0 - 50 °C
  • Storage temperature (T-T)
    • DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot:-40 - 70 °C
    • 28-Port PoE Fast Ethernet 10/100 Smart Switch (FS728TP):-20 - 70 °C

Side by side

Differences highlightedShow differences only (off)
Comparison of DES-3010GA, managed 8-Port 10/100 Switch + 1 Gigabit Port + 1 SFP Slot, FS728TP
58 specifications
Management featuresidentical
Switch typeManagedManaged
Quality of Service (QoS) supportYesYes
Web-based managementKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
System event logKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
Ports & interfaces1 differ
Basic switching RJ-45 Ethernet ports quantityDiffers824
Gigabit Ethernet (copper) ports quantityKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source4
SFP module slots quantityKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source2
SFP/SFP+ slots quantityKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source2
Power connectorKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceDC-in jack
Network2 differ
Networking standardsDiffersIEEE 802.1D, IEEE 802.1p, IEEE 802.1s, IEEE 802.1w, IEEE 802.1x, IEEE 802.3ad, IEEE 802.3u, IEEE 802.3xIEEE 802.3, IEEE 802.3ab, IEEE 802.3af, IEEE 802.3u, IEEE 802.3x, IEEE 802.3z
Port mirroringYesYes
Full duplexKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
Broadcast storm controlYesYes
Flow control supportYesYes
Link aggregationKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
Spanning tree protocolKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
Number of VLANsDiffers256128
Rate limitingKnown for oneYesUnknown — not stated by the source
Data transmission1 differ
MAC address tableKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source8000 entries
Store-and-forwardYesYes
Maximum data transfer rate1 Gbit/s1 Gbit/s
Packet buffer memoryDiffers0.128 MB3 MB
Switching capacityKnown for one5.6 Gbit/sUnknown — not stated by the source
Securityidentical
DHCP featuresDHCP clientDHCP client
Access Control List (ACL)Known for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
IGMP snoopingKnown for oneYesUnknown — not stated by the source
MAC address filteringKnown for oneYesUnknown — not stated by the source
Multicast featuresidentical
Multicast supportKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceYes
Designidentical
StackableNoNo
SafetyKnown for oneCSAUnknown — not stated by the source
Performanceidentical
Noise levelKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source49 dB
Mean time between failures (MTBF)Known for oneUnknown — not stated by the source176000 h
Power1 differ
Power consumption (typical)Differs12.2 W225 W
Power sourceKnown for one100 - 240 VAC, 50-60 HzUnknown — not stated by the source
Power over Ethernet (PoE)1 differ
Power over Ethernet (PoE)DiffersNoYes
Other features1 differ
LatencyKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source20 μs
Dimensions (WxDxH)Differs155 x 220 x 37 mm440 x 257 x 43 mm
Connectivity technologyWiredWired
BandwidthKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source12.8 Gbit/s
Authentication methodKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceIEEE 802.1x
Power requirementsKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source100 - 240 VAC, 50 - 60 Hz
Data transfer rateKnown for one100 Mbit/sUnknown — not stated by the source
Packet transfer speedKnown for one14,880/148,800/1,488,000ppsUnknown — not stated by the source
Dimensions (W x D x H) (imperial)Known for one154.9 x 220 x 36.8 mm (6.1 x 8.66 x 1.45")Unknown — not stated by the source
Electromagnetic emissionsKnown for oneCE A, FCC A, C-Tick, VCCI AUnknown — not stated by the source
I/O portsKnown for oneRJ-45: 10BASE-T, 100BASE-TX & 1000BASE-T SC: 1000BASE-X SFP, LCUnknown — not stated by the source
Technical featuresKnown for oneTFTP Client, BootP Client,SNMP v1/2/3, SNTP, TACACS+, SYSLOG, GVRPUnknown — not stated by the source
Weight (imperial)Known for one1.27 kg (2.8 lbs)Unknown — not stated by the source
Operational conditions3 differ
Operating temperature (T-T)Differs32 - 104 °F0 - 50 °C
Storage temperature (T-T)Differs-40 - 70 °C-20 - 70 °C
Operating relative humidity (H-H)Differs5 - 95%0 - 90%
Storage relative humidity (H-H)Known for oneUnknown — not stated by the source0 - 95%
Operating altitudeKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the source0 - 3000 m
Heat dissipationKnown for one41.6 BTU/hUnknown — not stated by the source
Weight & dimensions1 differ
WeightDiffers1.27 kg3.6 kg
Certificatesidentical
CertificationKnown for oneUnknown — not stated by the sourceCE mark FCC Part 15 Class A VCCI Class A C-Tick EN 55024 cUL IEC 950/EN 60950
Protocolsidentical
Management protocolsKnown for oneTelnet, CLI/Console, RMON, Web-based HTTP, SNMPv1/2/3, SSH, SSLUnknown — not stated by the source
Data link protocolsKnown for oneEthernet, Fast Ethernet, Gigabit EthernetUnknown — not stated by the source

A dash means the value is not stated by the source. Unknown values are never counted for or against a product, and there is no overall score.

More network switch comparisons

All network switch comparisons