Product comparison · 2 nas & storage servers

NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S vs QNAP HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105

104specifications compared
56differ
48identical
81known for one product only

Key differences

The NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S has 168 TB more total installed storage capacity than the QNAP HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105 (168 TB vs 0 TB). The NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S has 12 more storage drives installed than the QNAP HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105 (12 vs 0). The NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S has 2 GHz more processor frequency than the QNAP HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105 (3.5 GHz vs 1.5 GHz). Only the NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S has storage drives installed. Only the NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S has ECC supported by processor.

Storage drives installed
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:Yes
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:No
Total installed storage capacity
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:168 TB
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:0 TB
Number of storage drives installed
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:12
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:0
Installed storage drive type
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:HDD
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:No
Storage drive capacity
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:14 TB
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:0 GB
Processor family
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:Intel® Xeon® E3 v5
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:Intel® Celeron®
Processor model
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:E3-1245V5
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:J4105
Processor frequency
- ReadyNAS RR4312S:3.5 GHz
- HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105:1.5 GHz

Side by side

Differences highlightedShow differences only

Comparison of ReadyNAS RR4312S, HS-453DX
185 specifications	A NETGEAR ReadyNAS RR4312S View product	B QNAP HS-453DX NAS Tower Intel® Celeron® J4105 Model HS-453DX View product
Storage6 differ
Storage drives installedDiffers	Yes	No
Total installed storage capacityDiffers	168 TB	0 TB
Number of storage drives installedDiffers	12	0
Installed storage drive typeDiffers	HDD	No
Supported storage drive types	HDD & SSD	HDD & SSD
Storage drive capacityDiffers	14 TB	0 GB
Supported storage drive interfacesKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	M.2, Serial ATA III
Storage drive sizes supported	2.5,3.5"	2.5,3.5"
Number of M.2 (M & B) slotsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	2
RAID support	Yes	Yes
RAID levels	0, 1, 5, 6, 10, JBOD	0, 1, 5, 6, 10, JBOD
Online RAID migrationKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Online RAID expansionKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
RAID rebuildKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Hot-swap drive bays	Yes	Yes
Supported file systemsDiffers	FAT32, HFS+, NTFS, ext3, ext4	FAT32, HFS+, NTFS, exFAT, ext3, ext4
Bad block scanKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Number of storage drives supportedKnown for one	12	Unknown — not stated by the source
Storage drive interfaceKnown for one	Serial ATA III	Unknown — not stated by the source
Processor15 differ
Processor manufacturer	Intel	Intel
Processor familyDiffers	Intel® Xeon® E3 v5	Intel® Celeron®
Processor modelDiffers	E3-1245V5	J4105
Processor frequencyDiffers	3.5 GHz	1.5 GHz
Processor boost frequencyDiffers	3.9 GHz	2.5 GHz
Processor cores	4	4
Processor threadsDiffers	8	4
Processor cacheDiffers	8 MB	4 MB
CPU configuration (max)	1	1
ECC supported by processorDiffers	Yes	No
PCI Express configurationsDiffers	1x16, 1x8+2x4, 2x8	1x2, 1x2+2x1, 1x4, 2x1, 4x1
PCI Express slots versionDiffers	3.0	2.0
Processor codenameDiffers	Skylake	Gemini Lake
Processor lithography	14 nm	14 nm
Processor operating modes	64-bit	64-bit
Processor package sizeDiffers	37.5 x 37.5 mm	25 x 24 mm
Processor socketDiffers	LGA 1151 (Socket H4)	BGA 1090
Thermal Design Power (TDP)Differs	80 W	10 W
TjunctionKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	105 °C
On-board graphics card modelDiffers	Intel® HD Graphics P530	Intel® UHD Graphics 600
Maximum internal memory supported by processorDiffers	64 GB	8 GB
Conflict-Free processor	Yes	Yes
Bus typeKnown for one	DMI3	Unknown — not stated by the source
Processor cache typeKnown for one	Smart Cache	Unknown — not stated by the source
Processor seriesKnown for one	Intel Xeon E3-1200 v5	Unknown — not stated by the source
ScalabilityKnown for one	1S	Unknown — not stated by the source
SteppingKnown for one	R0	Unknown — not stated by the source
System bus rateKnown for one	8 GT/s	Unknown — not stated by the source
Memory bandwidth supported by processor (max)Known for one	34.1 GB/s	Unknown — not stated by the source
Memory3 differ
Internal memoryDiffers	16 GB	4 GB
Internal memory type	DDR4	DDR4
Maximum RAM supportedDiffers	128 GB	8 GB
Memory slotsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	2
Flash memoryDiffers	256 MB	4096 MB
Network2 differ
Ethernet LAN	Yes	Yes
Ethernet LAN data ratesDiffers	10,100,1000,10000 Mbit/s	10,100,1000,2500,5000,10000 Mbit/s
Wi-Fi	No	No
DHCP client	Yes	Yes
DHCP serverKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Jumbo frames support	Yes	Yes
iSCSI support	Yes	Yes
Wake-on-LAN readyKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Dynamic DNS (DDNS)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Fault toleranceKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Link aggregationKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Load balancing system	Yes	Yes
Supported network protocolsDiffers	TCP/IP, HTTP, HTTPS, FTP, SSH	TCP/IP, HTTP/HTTPS
Ethernet LAN data rate supported (max)Known for one	10000 Mbit/s	Unknown — not stated by the source
Ports & interfaces3 differ
Ethernet LAN (RJ-45) portsDiffers	4	2
USB port	Yes	Yes
USB 2.0 ports quantityDiffers	0	2
USB 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1) Type-A ports quantity	2	2
USB 3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1) Type-C ports quantityKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	1
Fiber ports quantityDiffers	2	0
HDMI ports quantityKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	2
HDMI versionKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	1.4b/2.0
3.5 mm (1/8-inch) outKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Microphone inKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Fiber optic connectorKnown for one	SFP+	Unknown — not stated by the source
eSATA ports quantityKnown for one	2	Unknown — not stated by the source
Graphics4 differ
On-board graphics card DirectX version	12.0	12.0
On-board graphics card IDDiffers	0x191D	0x3185
On-board graphics card base frequencyDiffers	400 MHz	250 MHz
On-board graphics card burst frequencyKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	750 MHz
On-board graphics card dynamic frequency (max)Differs	1150 MHz	750 MHz
Maximum on-board graphics card memoryDiffers	1 GB	8 GB
Number of displays supported (on-board graphics)	3	3
On-board graphics card OpenGL versionKnown for one	4.4	Unknown — not stated by the source
Design4 differ
Chassis typeDiffers	Rack (2U)	Tower
Product colourDiffers	Black	Gold, White
Number of fansDiffers	3 fan(s)	0 fan(s)
LED indicatorsDiffers	Yes	Status
Built-in speaker(s)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Number of built-in speakersKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	1
Cooling typeKnown for one	Active	Unknown — not stated by the source
Fan diameterKnown for one	8 cm	Unknown — not stated by the source
Performance3 differ
Type	NAS	NAS
Device classDiffers	Small & Medium Business	Home & Home Office
Backup function	Yes	Yes
Backup featuresDiffers	Cloud	Cloud, iSCSI LUN
Multilingual support	Yes	Yes
Noise levelKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	13 dB
Noise level (idle)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	6.2 dB
SnapshotKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Management protocolsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	SNMP v2/v3
Web-based management	Yes	Yes
Browser supportedDiffers	Microsoft Internet Explorer 9+, Mozilla Firefox 14+, Google Chrome 20+, Apple Safari 5+	Apple Safari 7+, Google Chrome, Microsoft Internet Explorer 10+, Mozilla Firefox
Built-in FTP serverKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Built-in iTunes server	Yes	Yes
Hot spare	Yes	Yes
On/off switchKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Remotely operatedKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Reset buttonKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
S.M.A.R.T. support	Yes	Yes
Security algorithmsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	256-bit AES, FIPS 140-2, HTTPS, SSH
Share folderKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	CIFS/SMB
System log	Yes	Yes
Number of usersKnown for one	8192 user(s)	Unknown — not stated by the source
Share folder access right managementKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Access Control List (ACL)Known for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Built-in UPnP AV media serverKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Network Time Protocol (NTP) clientKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Software4 differ
Operating system installedDiffers	ReadyNAS OS	QNAP Turbo System
Windows operating systems supportedDiffers	Windows 10, Windows 7, Windows 8, Windows 8.1	Windows 10, Windows 10 Education, Windows 10 Education x64, Windows 10 Enterprise, Windows 10 Enterprise x64, Windows 10 Home, Windows 10 Home x64, Windows 10 IOT Core, Windows 10 Pro, Windows 10 Pro x64, Windows 7, Windows 7 Enterprise, Windows 7 Enterprise x64, Windows 7 Home Basic, Windows 7 Home
Linux operating systems supported	Yes	Yes
Mac operating systems supportedDiffers	Yes	Mac OS X 10.10 Yosemite, Mac OS X 10.11 El Capitan, Mac OS X 10.12 Sierra, Mac OS X 10.13 High Sierra, Mac OS X 10.14 Mojave, Mac OS X 10.7 Lion, Mac OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion, Mac OS X 10.9 Mavericks
Server operating systems supportedDiffers	Windows Server 2008, Windows Server 2008 R2, Windows Server 2012	Windows Server 2003, Windows Server 2008 R2, Windows Server 2012, Windows Server 2012 R2, Windows Server 2016
Power2 differ
Power supply location	Built-in	Built-in
Power supply unit (PSU) capacityDiffers	550 W	90 W
Power consumption (typical)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	22.38 W
Power consumption (sleep)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	13.55 W
AC input voltageDiffers	100-240 V	100 - 240 V
Number of power supply unitsKnown for one	1	Unknown — not stated by the source
AC input frequencyKnown for one	50-60 Hz	Unknown — not stated by the source
Weight & dimensions3 differ
WidthDiffers	445 mm	404 mm
DepthDiffers	707 mm	220 mm
HeightDiffers	88 mm	42.8 mm
WeightKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	2.4 kg
Packaging contentidentical
External power adapterKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Cables includedKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	AC, LAN (RJ-45)
Quick installation guideKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Number of screwsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	16
Remote control includedKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Processor special features4 differ
Embedded options available	No	No
Enhanced Intel SpeedStep Technology	Yes	Yes
Execute Disable Bit	Yes	Yes
Idle States	Yes	Yes
Intel 64	Yes	Yes
Intel Enhanced Halt State	Yes	Yes
Intel Identity Protection Technology versionKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	1.00
Intel Secure Key Technology version	1.00	1.00
Intel Smart Response Technology versionKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	0.00
Intel VT-x with Extended Page Tables (EPT)	Yes	Yes
Intel Virtualization Technology (VT-x)	Yes	Yes
Intel Virtualization Technology for Directed I/O (VT-d)	Yes	Yes
Intel® AES New Instructions (Intel® AES-NI)	Yes	Yes
Intel® Anti-Theft Technology (Intel® AT)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	No
Intel® Hyper Threading Technology (Intel® HT Technology)Differs	Yes	No
Intel® Identity Protection Technology (Intel® IPT)Known for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Intel® OS Guard	Yes	Yes
Intel® Quick Sync Video Technology	Yes	Yes
Intel® Secure Key	Yes	Yes
Intel® Smart Response TechnologyKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	No
Intel® Turbo Boost TechnologyDiffers	2.0	No
Maximum number of PCI Express lanesDiffers	16	6
Number of execution unitsKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	12
Thermal Monitoring Technologies	Yes	Yes
Memory channels supported by processor	Dual	Dual
Memory types supported by processorDiffers	DDR3L-SDRAM, DDR4-SDRAM	DDR4-SDRAM, LPDDR4-SDRAM
Graphics & IMC lithographyKnown for one	14 nm	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel Clear Video TechnologyKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel TSX-NIKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel TSX-NI versionKnown for one	1.00	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel Trusted Execution TechnologyKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel® Clear Video HD Technology (Intel® CVT HD)Known for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel® Clear Video Technology for Mobile Internet Devices (Intel CVT for MID)Known for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel® InTru™ 3D TechnologyKnown for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel® Insider™Known for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Intel® Wireless Display (Intel® WiDi)Known for one	Yes	Unknown — not stated by the source
Memory voltage supported by processorKnown for one	1.35 V	Unknown — not stated by the source
Operational conditions2 differ
Operating temperature (T-T)Differs	0 - 40 °C	0 - 35 °C
Operating relative humidity (H-H)Differs	20 - 80%	5 - 95%
Other features1 differ
Digital Living Network Alliance (DLNA) certifiedKnown for one	Unknown — not stated by the source	Yes
Processor ARK IDDiffers	88173	128989
Compliance certificatesKnown for one	RoHS	Unknown — not stated by the source
CertificationKnown for one	FCC, CE, VCCI	Unknown — not stated by the source

A dash means the value is not stated by the source. Unknown values are never counted for or against a product, and there is no overall score.

More nas & storage servers comparisons

All nas & storage servers comparisons